Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lurker #59's avatar

One of the problems with modern science (more specifically of the endowed and federally funded sort) is that it is too cautious. Risk and novelty is not the way to get grants. Rather things are done in a safe plodding manner.

If anyone has paid any attention to Trump, he is not risk averse with his business practices but he immediately pivots should the risk fail to pay off. This was very much on display in the Apprentice where he rewarded contestants who were willing to intelligently take risks/gambles. You can see this with various policies that he had during his time as president as well where he makes calculated risks and immediately pivots should things not work. It is a great combination of forward thinking and pragmatism. "Operation Warp Speed" is very much in line with with this thinking (along with the plethora of outside of the box treatment ideas that he also wanted to get into the mainstream). I do think that it was the right choice to pursue, given what was known at the time, and it was and is a good idea to unshackle science.

The problem is that the whole process got co-opted by politics and agenda driven scientists. Lots can be said about bad philosophy (of science) behind everything and political opportunists wresting control of things.

I will say one thing: Herd inoculation, even of experimental drugs, is absolutely the correct procedure in the time pandemic given the data set at the time (which we now know was fudged). However, man is not an animal which makes herd inoculation completely immoral. The problem is that many, and especially on the left, consider man to only be an animal. Philosophy tells us that man is more than just an animal. Faith tells us that man is imago dei. Many simply hate that and so much of what we see in culture, in politics, (and sadly amongst Christians), regarding the pandemic and what followed was done from positions diametrically opposed and would respond with venom towards those who would approach the situation believing that man is more than an animal.

Customary plug for

The Andromeda Strain by Crichton

The Hot Zone by Preston

both necessary reads for how messy, unknowing, and, especially, inept the actual "scientific process" when it is in the middle of things. Science is messy like politics -- it works best when people are shouting at each other and not one side keeping the other from speaking.

Expand full comment
Carol A O'Malley's avatar

Excellent Dan!!!

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts